A content gap analysis used to mean "keywords competitors rank for that we don't". In AI search it has three layers: keyword gaps, prompt gaps (where AI names competitors instead of you) and source gaps (where the sites AI cites never mention you). Each layer points to different work, from new pages to reviews and PR.
The three gaps
| Gap | Question it answers | Typical fix |
|---|---|---|
| Keyword gap | Which queries do competitors rank for that we don't? | New or improved pages |
| Prompt gap | Which buyer prompts name competitors but not us? | Content plus off-site authority |
| Source gap | Which cited sources mention competitors but not us? | Reviews, lists, PR, partnerships |
Step 1: Choose competitors
Include the brands AI actually names in your category. They're often different from the ones you consider rivals. Run a few category prompts first to find them. See AI competitor benchmarking.
Step 2: Find keyword gaps
Use a keyword tool's competitor comparison to list queries where competitors rank in the top 10 and you don't. Filter to queries with commercial or strong informational value. Check Search Console for queries where you have impressions but weak positions.
Step 3: Find prompt gaps
- Build 40–80 buyer prompts across intents. See building a prompt tracking set.
- Run each in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode, several times.
- Record who's named, in what position, and what reasons AI gives.
- List prompts where competitors appear and you don't.
The reasons matter: "known for strong integrations" tells you what proof to publish.
Step 4: Find source gaps
For each prompt gap, list the cited sources. For each source, note whether it mentions you. See citation source analysis.
| Source type | Gap fix |
|---|---|
| Review platform | Review campaign, complete profile. See G2 and Capterra |
| Best-of list | Outreach to the publisher. See best-of lists |
| Publication | Digital PR. See digital PR for AEO |
| Community thread | Genuine participation. See Reddit and AI answers |
| Competitor's own page | Publish your own fair comparison |
Step 5: Compare page by page
For your most important gaps, compare your best page with the competitor page AI cites:
- Does theirs answer the question in the first lines?
- Does it include specifics (prices, specs, steps) yours lacks?
- Is it fresher?
- Does it cover follow-up questions?
See how to write content AI assistants cite.
Step 6: Prioritise
Score each gap on:
- Value: closeness to revenue
- Size: how often the question is asked or searched
- Effort: new page, rewrite, or off-site campaign
- Winnability: your authority and the sources' openness
Start with high-value, lower-effort gaps: often rewrites of existing pages and one or two list inclusions.
Turning gaps into a plan
| Gap type | Owner | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Keyword | SEO/content | New pages, rewrites |
| Prompt | Content + PR | Comparison pages, proof, outreach |
| Source | PR/partnerships | Reviews, list inclusion, coverage |
Feed the plan into an AEO content calendar.
Measuring progress
Re-run the same prompts monthly. Track how many prompt gaps closed, new citations of your pages, and new mentions on target sources. See AI share of voice.
A gap tracker you can copy
| Prompt | Intent | Competitors named | You named? | Top cited sources | Mentions you? | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| best X for Y | Decide | A, B, C | No | list site, G2, Reddit | No | Pitch list; review campaign |
| A vs you | Compare | A | Yes, #2 | A's page, review site | Partly | Publish own comparison |
Keep one row per prompt and update it monthly. Over a quarter, the tracker shows which actions closed gaps and which didn't, which is far more useful than a one-off report.
Common mistakes
- Comparing yourself only with the competitors you know, not the ones AI names
- Treating every gap as a content gap when many are source gaps
- Running prompts once and drawing conclusions
The bottom line
The gaps that cost you deals today are the prompts where AI names a competitor and the sources that tell it to. Find both, fix the pages you control, and earn your way into the sources you don't.
