When an AI assistant builds a shortlist, it often leans on "best of" roundups, because those articles are literally lists of recommendations with reasons. Being included in several independent, well-regarded lists is one of the strongest ways to get into AI answers for recommendation prompts. Here's a repeatable process for earning those places.
For how assistants use roundups, see "Best X for Y" lists: how AI assistants use them.
Step 1: Build your target list
- Run your recommendation prompts across assistants and record every roundup cited. See citation analysis.
- Search the matching queries ("best [category] for [use case]") and note top-ranking roundups.
- Add niche lists for your strongest use cases, even if they're smaller.
For each, record: URL, author, last updated date, whether you're included, how you're described, and how often it's cited by AI.
Step 2: Prioritize
Score each list by:
- AI citation frequency for your prompts
- Use-case fit: does it match a use case you're genuinely strong in?
- Update frequency: lists updated regularly are reachable
- Gap: are you absent, or present but poorly described?
Start with frequently cited, well-matched, regularly updated lists where you're missing.
Step 3: Prepare a pitch kit
Have this ready before contacting anyone:
- One-sentence description and a clear "best for" statement
- Key facts: pricing, plans, free trial, platforms, integrations
- Two or three differentiators, each with evidence (a review quote, a metric, a customer example)
- Screenshots and a short demo video
- Trial or demo access for the author
- A contact who can answer questions quickly
Step 4: Pitch the author
Keep it short, specific and useful. Reference the list, explain the fit, offer access, and don't ask for a ranking:
"Hi [Name], your guide to [category] for [use case] is one of the most useful I've read. We built [Brand] specifically for [use case]: [one-line differentiator]. If you're updating the guide, I'd be glad to set up an account or a 15-minute walkthrough. Current pricing and screenshots are here: [link]."
Personalize every pitch. Mass templates are easy to spot and easy to ignore.
Step 5: Make evaluation easy
If the author tries your product:
- Give them a fully featured account without time pressure
- Offer a guided setup if your product needs configuration
- Answer questions fast and honestly, including about limitations
Step 6: Correct and update
If you're already listed but described inaccurately (old pricing, missing features), send a polite correction with a source. When you launch something relevant to a list's criteria, let the author know once, briefly.
Step 7: Build relationships
Writers who cover your category repeatedly are worth knowing over time:
- Share genuinely useful data or insights, not just product news
- Offer expert commentary for their other articles
- Thank them when they include you, and don't pressure them about rankings
Step 8: Strengthen the signals authors look at
Authors check reviews, reputation and other coverage. Make sure:
- Your reviews are recent and specific
- Your product and pricing pages are clear. See product pages for AI assistants.
- Your use-case pages explain the fit for the list's audience
What not to do
- Pay for undisclosed placements
- Send aggressive or repeated follow-ups
- Misrepresent features or pricing
- Ask to be ranked above competitors
- Create fake "independent" review sites
Measuring success
- Number of priority lists you're included in, and how you're described
- Mention rate and share of voice on the matching "best for" prompts. See AI share of voice.
- Referral traffic from the lists themselves
A tracking sheet for roundup outreach
| List | Author | Cited by AI? | Updated | Included? | Description of us | Last contact | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best CRMs for agencies | J. Smith | Often | Quarterly | No | — | — | Send pitch kit |
| Top CRMs for small teams | Editorial team | Sometimes | Yearly | Yes | Old pricing | Mar | Send correction |
| CRMs with Gmail integration | A. Lee | Often | Monthly | No | — | — | Offer trial |
A simple sheet like this keeps outreach organized, prevents duplicate pitches and makes progress visible in your monthly reporting.
The bottom line
Getting into "best of" lists is a process: find the lists AI cites, prioritize by fit and impact, pitch authors with everything they need, make evaluation easy, keep your details current and build relationships over time. Each independent inclusion strengthens the consensus that puts your brand on AI shortlists.
