Hire an AEO agency for three things: a measurement method you can verify, sound judgment about which content and sources will move AI answers, and honesty about what nobody controls. Polished decks and confident promises are easy to produce in a new field; evidence is harder. This guide covers when to hire, what to ask, red flags, a scoring sheet and the contract terms to agree before you sign.
Decide whether you need an agency
Before writing an RFP, decide what you're buying. Agencies are useful when you lack one of these:
- Strategy and measurement expertise: building a prompt set, interpreting variable results, setting priorities
- Execution capacity: content restructuring, new pages, technical fixes
- Outreach: digital PR, roundup inclusion, review programs, community strategy
If your team can execute and only needs measurement, a tool plus an internal owner may be enough. See building an in-house AEO team and how to choose an AEO tool.
What good looks like
A strong AEO agency can show you, specifically:
- A documented method for prompt sets, repeated runs and metrics
- Sample deliverables: an audit, a monthly report, a roadmap (anonymized)
- How they find which sources AI cites in a category and what they do about it
- A realistic 90-day plan with dates and owners
- The named people who will do the work, and their experience
- Clear limits: what they won't do and won't promise
The RFP question list
Send these questions in writing and ask for specific answers, not marketing copy.
Method and measurement
- How do you build a prompt set for a company like ours, and how many prompts would you track?
- Which AI platforms do you track, and why those?
- How many times do you run each prompt, and how do you handle variability between runs? See why AI answers change every time.
- Which metrics do you report, and how is each calculated?
- What tools do you use, and do we get access to the raw data?
- How do you connect AI visibility to traffic, leads or revenue?
Strategy and execution
- How do you identify the third-party sources AI cites in our category?
- What does your audit include? Can we see an anonymized example? See what a great AEO audit deliverable includes.
- What would you expect to change in the first 90 days, and what takes longer?
- Which work do you do, and which do you expect our team to do?
- How do you handle inaccurate information about a brand in AI answers?
- How do you work with our existing SEO, content and PR teams or agencies?
Ethics and risk
- Do you use paid reviews, fake accounts, undisclosed sponsored posts or automated community posting? (The answer should be no.)
- What do you never promise clients?
- How do you handle conflicts if you work with our competitors?
Commercials and team
- Who exactly will work on our account, and what share of their time?
- How is pricing structured, and what counts as a scope change?
- What are the notice period and exit terms, and what do we keep if we leave?
A live test: ask for a sample
The most revealing step is a small sample on your own brand. Give each shortlisted agency five to ten of your real prompts and ask them to bring results to the final meeting: what the answers say, who's named, which sources are cited, and two or three recommendations. You'll see how they think, how carefully they handle variability, and whether their recommendations are specific. Pay for this if it's substantial; it's worth it.
Red flags
| Red flag | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| "Guaranteed placement in ChatGPT" | No one controls AI answers; guarantees signal either naivety or deception |
| "Secret method" or "we know the algorithm" | Good AEO is explainable |
| Single screenshots as proof | One run proves little; ask for repeated-run data |
| Fake reviews, sockpuppet accounts or paid posts without disclosure | Breaks platform rules and can damage your brand when exposed |
| No raw data access | You can't verify results or switch providers |
| Reports with no documented method | Trends can't be trusted or compared |
| Every recommendation is "publish more content" | Ignores sources, accuracy and technical access |
| Bundled "AI optimization" with no defined units | Scope and value can't be checked |
Many of these come from beliefs covered in the most common AEO myths.
A scoring sheet
Score each finalist 1 to 5 on each criterion and multiply by the weight. Adjust weights to your needs.
| Criterion | Weight | Agency A | Agency B | Agency C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Measurement method and data access | 25% | |||
| Quality of sample on our prompts | 20% | |||
| Source and content strategy | 15% | |||
| Team experience and allocation | 15% | |||
| Ethics and transparency | 10% | |||
| Fit with our teams and tools | 5% | |||
| Price and terms | 10% |
Have two or three people score independently, then compare. Big disagreements usually point to a question nobody asked.
Contract terms to agree
- Scope in countable units: prompts, platforms, competitors, markets, pages, outreach targets
- Deliverables and dates for the first 90 days
- Measurement method written into an appendix
- No-guarantee clause that is honest about AI variability
- Data ownership: you own prompt sets, results, content and accounts created for you
- Access and credentials: managed through your accounts where possible
- Ethics clause: no fake reviews, undisclosed paid placements or inauthentic accounts
- Exit terms: notice period and handover of data and documents
For what a well-structured offer looks like, see the AEO proposal template.
Example: shortlisting three agencies
This example is illustrative. A consumer finance brand sends the RFP to five agencies and shortlists three. Agency A has the best deck but offers "top placement in AI answers" and won't share raw data. Agency B brings a careful sample on eight prompts, showing ranges across runs and a review site with outdated rates that's cited on four of them. Agency C is the cheapest but proposes only blog content.
Scored independently by the marketing lead, the SEO manager and a finance partner, Agency B wins on method, sample and ethics despite a higher price. The contract includes an audit, a monthly retainer with defined units, data ownership and a 60-day exit clause.
If you're comparing providers in India, see what AEO and GEO cost in India.
The bottom line
Choose an AEO agency on evidence: a documented method, a thoughtful sample on your own prompts, specific source and content strategy, named people and clear limits. Avoid anyone who guarantees placements or uses inauthentic tactics, score finalists on a weighted sheet, and write scope, data ownership and exit terms into the contract.
